Matt Coyne’s ‘The
Trouble with Sister Francis’ is a warm, funny and feelgood novel (Review by Margaret von Klemperer, courtesy of The Witness)
Set in the north of England in the 1980s, with a parallel
story from the early years of the Second World War, Matt
Coyne’s The Trouble with Sister Francis
is a warm, funny and feelgood novel – good holiday reading.
The central characters are four 11-year-old kids from a council estate in the north of England: Richie, Bennet, Kenny and Stan. And, of course, Sister Francis. She is a most unlikely nun who smokes like a chimney, swears like a trooper, and has a remarkable past which the reader learns about as the novel progresses.
The boys have time on their hands, and there is not much to
do except get into mischief. Richie, the first-person narrator, lost his father
some time before and lives with his mother and grandfather while Kenny has a
troubled home life. Then they get to hear about the reopening of a boys’ club
at the local church, and, under pressure from Riche’s mum, they go along,
expecting very little.
The club is being run by the alarming Sister Francis, and the first thing she does is put the boys to clearing up the ancient premises – and that is where Richie finds the old wartime diary, written by a teenager evacuated to the area from London. Excerpts from the diary intersperse the text, and we learn about the early days of the club from them. They give a context to the 1980s story, and gradually, deeper links will be revealed, links that are poignant to the point of tragedy.
As the boys develop their relationship with Sister Francis, they come to respect her – and her determination to make the club work, despite the considerable obstacles that are put in her way, often by the church itself. And she will take on anyone, from a nastily snobbish local priest, to the bishop, to the local thugs if she feels the need to protect her club and her boys.
Coyne does a pretty good job of getting the voice of an 11-year-old right. There are, particularly in the first two-thirds of the book, plenty of very funny moments, but Coyne also knows how to pull at the heartstrings, and makes sure that he does.
The long arm of coincidence is sometimes stretched pretty thin, but The Trouble with Sister Francis works well as what it sets out to be – a warm, feelgood tale set in a past that it makes the reader realise was very different from our difficult, contemporary world. - Margaret von Klemperer
The Trouble with Sister Francis is published by Wildfire: ISBN 978-1-03-542507-5


