Review of My Cape Town

Thursday, November 19, 2026

KZNPO SPRING SEASON CONCERT 1: REVIEW

 


KZN Philharmonic Orchestra World Symphony Series – Spring Season Concert 1

The Playhouse Opera: Thursday November 12, 2026

 

Since the roster of regular symphony concerts has slowed to a comparative trickle (nine in all for 2026), every such occasion is now invested with unusual importance. With so few slots, it may be said that there is no room for poor choice of repertoire: naturally, that has meant safe options, with no experiments or diversions.

This is a far cry from the aspirational efforts made pre- and post-2000 to move the orchestra into a contemporary South African ambit. Neither are sub-par performances welcome, which means every visiting conductor and soloist is put to the test. In this case, it was conductor Jean-Claude Picard and pianist Polina Osetinskaya, both making their Durban debuts.

This, the first concert of two that will conclude the symphonic year, comprised two large-scale works, both of them the most popular of their respective composers’ output: Rachmaninov’s Piano Concerto No. 2 and Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5. From the famous opening chords of the former, Ms Osetinskaya drew in her audience, and with the orchestra leaning into the long-breathed melodies behind her cascades of arpeggios, the scene was set for enthralment.

One of the startling effects of attending a live performance after a diet of recordings is to have the haze of technological interventions like equalizing and balancing torn away by the raw effects.

Not all are welcome: the piano’s highest notes ping rather than sing, and the lowest notes rumble (both are part of Rachmaninov’s extensive language), but between them are registers of warmth and, when necessary, brilliance that the soloist exploited to the full. Her reading of the concerto tended to the ‘power-playing’ side, but that was bracing even if the first movement seemed more weighted toward the episodic than usual.

Picard kept the orchestra on a tight rein, which is vital in this score as well as tricky at some of its corners, and Dylan Barker’s solo horn playing gave a consistently sensitive lead.

Encores also tell part of the story, and her offering of Rachmaninov’s Prelude, Op 23, No 4 served as a traversal in small of the concerto’s melodiousness and complex accompanying figures. Every note was consciously sculpted and the projection bold.  A virtuoso ‘throwaway’ followed, a brief, hectic version of the Hopak (Ukrainian dance imagined by Mussorgsky, in a Rachmaninov arrangement) that ended in a flurry of scintillating runs. We were fortunate to have been swept along by Ms Osetinskaya’s mastery and aplomb.

Picard and the orchestra had the field to themselves after interval and brought an energy and delight to the many details of the Tchaikovsky symphony. The expressive range was enormous, from the ominous opening utterances, through the tender charm of the waltz (3rd movement), to the frequent stentorian brass passages which gave unusual exposure to the team of 2 trumpets, 3 trombones and a tuba, and sometimes with horns backing them.

Personally, I found their assertiveness more than a touch relentless, but close inspection of the score shows that the conductor was doing exactly what the composer had asked: the brass play at a default fortissimo, and sometimes a notch or even two above that! It is a matter for speculation why Tchaikovsky kept pushing the aural limits of the orchestra in this way. Of course, it requires from the strings and woodwind a concomitant force which Picard finely elicited. These were performances to file in memory as yardsticks for future repeats or for other works by these composers. - David Smith

For more information on the KZNPO, click on the advert at the top right-hand side of this article.

 

NB:

The second and final concert of the KZN Philharmonic Orchestra World Symphony Series – Spring Season will take place tonight at 19h30 in the Playhouse Drama. Booking is at Quicket.